Ranked #1 in Worthington
Based in Westerville, 6 mi away
62/100LFR Score
Ranked #1 because of its Google rating and review volume: 4.9★ from 114 Google reviews.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Insurance Lawyers in Worthington, OH: 2026 rankings
26 insurance lawyers ranked by LFR ScoreUpdated 0 paid placements in this rankingHow we rank →
The short answer
- 1
Highest LFR Score in Worthington: Pencheff and Fraley Injury and Accident Attorneys, LFR Score 62/100; 4.9★ from 114 Google reviews; open 24/7.
- 2
Open 24 hours (per Google): Monge & Associates Injury and Accident Attorneys, posts 24/7 hours; ranked #2 of 26.
- 5
Most-reviewed: Calig Law Firm, 322 Google reviews at 5.0★, the most of 26 ranked; ranked #5.
Rankings can't be bought. Lawyers can't pay to change their rank or score. How we rank
26 Worthington insurance lawyers are ranked here by LFR Score, from nine published factors. 7 are open 24/7, 7 open Saturdays and 7 open Sundays, based on posted hours. The median Google rating is 4.7★ across 26 rated law firms.
Most of this list also appears on the Insurance lawyers in Newark ranking. See Insurance lawyers in Newark
Top 10 insurance lawyers in Worthington at a glance
Ranked by our published LFR Score from public data, not by payment; a rank is not an endorsement or a prediction of results.
| Rank | Business | LFR Score | Google rating | Based in | Hours | Notable for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pencheff and Fraley Injury and Accident Attorneys | 62 | 4.9★ (114) | Westerville, 6 mi away | Open 24 hrs (Google) | Top score |
| 2 | Monge & Associates Injury and Accident Attorneys | 61 | 4.9★ (110) | Columbus, 9 mi away | Open 24 hrs (Google) | Open 24 hours |
| 3 | Columbus Personal Injury Attorney at Law, Brandon J. Broderick | 60 | 5.0★ (57) | Columbus, 10 mi away | Open 24 hrs (Google) | — |
| 4 | Rohrbacher Trimble & Zimmerman Co., L.P.A. | 59 | 5.0★ (6) | Westerville, 4 mi away | — | — |
| 5 | Calig Law Firm | 59 | 5.0★ (322) | Columbus, 9 mi away | — | Most reviews |
| 6 | NRS Injury Law | 58 | 4.9★ (219) | Columbus, 4 mi away | — | — |
| 7 | Thomas & Co | 58 | 3.0★ (3) | Delaware, 15 mi away | — | — |
| 8 | Schuerger Shunnarah Trial Attorneys | 58 | 3.8★ (157) | Columbus, 2 mi away | Open 24 hrs (Google) | — |
| 9 | Callinan and Wisecup Law Firm | 57 | 4.3★ (54) | Columbus, 9 mi away | Open 24 hrs (Google) | — |
| 10 | Law Office of Joel Moore | 57 | 5.0★ (13) | Worthington | Open 24 hrs (Google) | — |
All 26 insurance lawyers in Worthington, in rank order
Ordered by LFR Score, a 0–100 score from nine published factors. Paid placement never changes the order.
Ranked by our published LFR Score from public data, not by payment; a rank is not an endorsement or a prediction of results.
Based in Columbus, 9 mi away
61/100LFR ScoreRanked #2 because of its Google rating and review volume: 4.9★ from 110 Google reviews.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Columbus, 10 mi away
60/100LFR ScoreRanked #3 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 5.0★ from 57 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Personal injury attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Westerville, 4 mi away
59/100LFR ScoreRanked #4 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 5.0★ from 6 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Insurance attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Columbus, 9 mi away
59/100LFR ScoreRanked #5 because of its Google rating and review volume: 5.0★ from 322 Google reviews, the most in Worthington.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Columbus, 4 mi away
58/100LFR ScoreRanked #6 because of its Google rating and review volume: 4.9★ from 219 Google reviews.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
#7 Thomas & Co
Based in Delaware, 15 mi away
58/100LFR ScoreRanked #7 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 3.0★ from 3 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Insurance attorney”.
Based on 6 of 9 factors; bar status, recency and availability not yet collected.
Based in Columbus, 2 mi away
58/100LFR ScoreRanked #8 because of its Google rating and review volume: 3.8★ from 157 Google reviews.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Columbus, 9 mi away
57/100LFR ScoreRanked #9 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 4.3★ from 54 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Personal injury attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Worthington
57/100LFR ScoreRanked #10 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 5.0★ from 13 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Personal injury attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Columbus, 9 mi away
56/100LFR ScoreRanked #11 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 4.8★ from 17 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Law firm”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
#12 Stegner Dennis E
Based in Springfield, 43 mi away
56/100LFR ScoreRanked #12 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 4.9★ from 12 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Insurance attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Dublin, 6 mi away
53/100LFR ScoreRanked #13 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 4.7★ from 31 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Personal injury attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Powell, 5 mi away
53/100LFR ScoreRanked #14 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 4.8★ from 25 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Law firm”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
#15 Harris & Engler
Based in Columbus, 3 mi away
52/100LFR ScoreRanked #15 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 4.8★ from 18 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Law firm”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Worthington
51/100LFR ScoreRanked #16 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 4.4★ from 9 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Civil law attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Delaware, 15 mi away
50/100LFR ScoreRanked #17 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 4.4★ from 7 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Attorney”.
Based on 6 of 9 factors; bar status, recency and availability not yet collected.
Based in Columbus, 9 mi away
50/100LFR ScoreRanked #18 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 4.3★ from 12 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
#19 Thomas Law
Based in Columbus, 10 mi away
50/100LFR ScoreRanked #19 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 4.6★ from 10 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Civil law attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
#20 Perez Morris
Based in Columbus, 2 mi away
50/100LFR ScoreRanked #20 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 3.5★ from 10 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Law firm”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
#21 Curt Sybert Esq
Based in Powell, 5 mi away
49/100LFR ScoreRanked #21 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 5.0★ from 5 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Columbus, 9 mi away
49/100LFR ScoreRanked #22 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 4.4★ from 7 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Bankruptcy attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
#23 Taft Law
Based in Columbus, 9 mi away
49/100LFR ScoreRanked #23 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 3.5★ from 11 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
#24 Heald & Long
Based in Delaware, 15 mi away
49/100LFR ScoreRanked #24 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 3.8★ from 16 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Family law attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
Based in Columbus, 8 mi away
48/100LFR ScoreRanked #25 because of its Google rating and practice area focus: 2.7★ from 10 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Employment attorney”.
Based on 7 of 9 factors; bar status and recency not yet collected.
How we ranked Worthington insurance lawyers
We scored 26 Worthington insurance lawyers on nine factors, weighted as shown. A law firm is ranked when its practice area is confirmed and it has 3 or more Google reviews or a claimed profile. A law firm with no Google reviews scores zero on rating, review volume and recency. Other unknown factors are left out, not counted as zero. Scores last refreshed November 9, 2026.
Paid placement never changes a rank or score. Attorney advertising businesses are paid, labelled, limited to 3 and shown above the ranking, outside it.
| Factor | Weight | Computed from | In Worthington data |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reputation | 25% | Google star rating, adjusted for how many reviews back it | Measured |
| Bar status | 10% | An active bar or law society record matched to a lawyer at the firm (not measured until a record source is loaded) | Not yet collected |
| Review volume | 10% | Number of Google reviews, compared with the most-reviewed firm on the list | Measured |
| Recency | 10% | Share of reviews from the last 12 months | Not yet collected |
| Availability | 5% | Weekly office hours, Saturday, Sunday, and phones answered 24/7 | Measured |
| Practice focus | 15% | How clearly the firm practises this area (its Google category and name) | Measured |
| Proximity | 5% | An office in the city scores highest, less the farther away it is | Measured |
| Claimed profile | 10% | The firm has claimed its Law Firms Ranked profile (free and paid earn the same) | Measured |
| Law Firms Ranked reviews | 10% | Verified client reviews collected by Law Firms Ranked: their rating and how many there are | Measured |
How to choose an insurance lawyer
- Check the lawyer’s status and any public discipline in the state bar or law society directory.
- Ask how many insurance law matters the lawyer handles each year, and who at the firm will do the work.
- Get the fee arrangement in writing: hourly, flat or contingency, and which costs are charged on top.
- Ask how and how often the firm will update you, and how fast it answers calls and emails.
- Read recent reviews for how the firm communicated and billed, not only for outcomes.
- Ask whether the firm represents policyholders, insurers or both, and how often it handles your type of policy.
- Meet more than one firm; many offer a short first consultation, sometimes free.
Questions to ask an insurance lawyer
- How would you approach a matter like mine, and what are the realistic options?
- How do you charge, and what will the total likely cost?
- Who will be my main contact, and how quickly do you reply?
- Do you represent policyholders or insurance companies?
- How is your fee calculated if the claim settles?
- Is there any conflict of interest that would stop you representing me?
Terms explained
- Contingency fee
- A fee that is a share of the money recovered, paid only if there is a recovery. Common in injury cases; not allowed for criminal defense or for securing a divorce.
- Retainer
- Money paid up front and held in a trust account, which the lawyer draws on as fees are earned.
- Flat fee
- One set price for a defined piece of work, such as a will or an uncontested matter.
- Limited-scope representation
- Paying a lawyer for part of a matter only, such as reviewing documents or coaching for one hearing (also called unbundled services).
- Statute of limitations
- The deadline to file a lawsuit or charge. It differs by state or province and by type of claim.
- Good standing
- A lawyer’s status as active and eligible to practise with a state bar or law society.
- Law society
- The body that licenses and disciplines lawyers in a Canadian province or territory.
- Board certification
- Recognition in a field of law by a state program or an organisation accredited for that purpose. Lawyers may only claim it when they hold it, naming the certifying body.
- Attorney–client privilege
- The rule that keeps confidential communications between a client and lawyer, made for legal advice, out of court.
- Conflict check
- The search a firm runs before taking a matter to make sure it does not represent someone on the other side.
- Pro bono
- Legal work done for free, usually for people who cannot afford a lawyer.
- Legal aid
- Publicly funded legal help for people with low incomes, through legal aid offices, public defenders or provincial legal aid plans.
Insurance lawyers in Worthington: frequently asked questions
Which insurance lawyer has the highest LFR Score in Worthington?
By LFR Score, the highest-ranked insurance lawyer in Worthington, OH is Pencheff and Fraley Injury and Accident Attorneys with an LFR Score of 62/100. It has 4.9★ from 114 Google reviews. It is open 24/7. Monge & Associates Injury and Accident Attorneys (#2) and Columbus Personal Injury Attorney at Law, Brandon J. Broderick (#3) follow. We ranked 26 insurance lawyers on nine factors, last updated November 9, 2026.
How many insurance lawyers are there in Worthington?
LawFirmsRanked ranks 26 insurance lawyers serving Worthington, OH. 2 of them are based in Worthington; the rest serve it from nearby towns. Counts are as of November 2026.
Which insurance lawyers in Worthington are open 24/7?
7 ranked insurance lawyers in Worthington post 24/7 hours. The highest-ranked are Pencheff and Fraley Injury and Accident Attorneys (#1), Monge & Associates Injury and Accident Attorneys (#2) and Columbus Personal Injury Attorney at Law, Brandon J. Broderick (#3). Hours come from each law firm's Google listing as of November 2026, so call to confirm.
Which insurance lawyers in Worthington work on weekends?
7 of 26 ranked insurance lawyers post Saturday hours and 7 post Sunday hours. The highest-ranked open Saturdays are Pencheff and Fraley Injury and Accident Attorneys (#1), Monge & Associates Injury and Accident Attorneys (#2) and Columbus Personal Injury Attorney at Law, Brandon J. Broderick (#3). Posted hours are office hours; many firms meet clients by appointment outside them.
What Google rating do Worthington insurance lawyers have?
The median Google rating among 26 rated insurance lawyers in Worthington is 4.7★, with a median of 15 reviews. Calig Law Firm has the most, 322 reviews, and ranks #5. We adjust ratings for review count, so a few five-star reviews cannot top the list.
How does LawFirmsRanked rank insurance lawyers?
Each insurance lawyer gets a 0–100 LFR Score from nine published factors, led by reputation (25%), practice focus (15%), review volume (10%) and recency (10%). A law firm with no Google reviews scores zero on rating, review volume and recency; other factors we cannot measure are left out. Only law firms with a confirmed practice area and 3 or more reviews, or a claimed profile, are ranked.
Do insurance lawyers outside Worthington count in this ranking?
Yes, if they are within 50 mi of the Worthington city center, our service radius for insurance lawyers. Each listing shows where the law firm is based and how far away it is. Proximity is 5% of the LFR Score, so a nearby law firm gets a small edge.
Can insurance lawyers pay to rank higher on LawFirmsRanked?
No. The LFR Score never reads payment status, and this ranking has 0 paid placements. Up to 3 Featured law firms may appear above the list, labelled Attorney advertising and showing their honest rank.
How do insurance lawyers in Worthington, OH charge?
Lawyers for policyholders often work on contingency or a mix of hourly and contingency fees; lawyers defending insurers bill hourly. Ask for the fee arrangement in writing before you agree.
What can I do if my insurer denies or underpays a claim?
Ask the insurer for the denial in writing with the policy wording it relies on, keep every document, and note any deadline in the policy or the letter. Every state has an insurance department that takes complaints; a lawyer can advise whether the denial can be challenged and how long you have. This is general information, not legal advice.
How is this list of insurance lawyers in Worthington, OH ranked?
By LFR Score only, from public data on reviews, practice focus, office location and hours. Firms labelled “Attorney advertising” paid for that placement; payment never changes a rank, and a rank is not an endorsement.
Does a lawyer need an office in Worthington?
No, but the lawyer must be licensed in your state (or, for federal matters such as immigration, in some state). A local office makes meetings and court appearances easier, so proximity is one of our factors.
Update log for Worthington
- November 2026: LFR Scores recalculated for 26 insurance lawyers serving Worthington.
More insurance lawyers and Worthington pages
Insurance lawyers near Worthington
- Insurance lawyers in Dublin, OH26 ranked
- Insurance lawyers in Westerville, OH28 ranked
- Insurance lawyers in Powell, OH27 ranked
- Insurance lawyers in Upper Arlington, OH27 ranked
- Insurance lawyers in Lewis Center, OH28 ranked
- Insurance lawyers in Hilliard, OH30 ranked
- Insurance lawyers in Gahanna, OH28 ranked
- Insurance lawyers in Columbus, OH27 ranked
- Insurance lawyers in Bexley, OH28 ranked
- Insurance lawyers in Whitehall, OH28 ranked
Other practice areas in Worthington
- Personal injury lawyers in Worthington197 ranked
- Social Security disability lawyers in Worthington30 ranked
- Criminal defense lawyers in Worthington122 ranked
- Divorce and family lawyers in Worthington187 ranked
- Estate planning and probate lawyers in Worthington144 ranked
- Bankruptcy lawyers in Worthington83 ranked
- Immigration lawyers in Worthington41 ranked
- Employment lawyers in Worthington58 ranked
- Business lawyers in Worthington27 ranked
- Real estate lawyers in Worthington73 ranked
- Tax lawyers in Worthington34 ranked
- Intellectual property lawyers in Worthington13 ranked
- Mediators in Worthington14 ranked
- General practice lawyers in Worthington403 ranked
- All lawyers in Worthington